Plumas Lake Housing Market Report – May 2026
Here's a look at how the Plumas Lake, CA real estate market performed in May 2026, based on actual sold data from the MLS.
Market Snapshot
- Homes Sold: 24
- Median Sale Price: $511,000
- Average Sale Price: $514,400
- Average Price Per Sq Ft: $249
- Average Days on Market: 65
- Sale-to-List Price Ratio: 100.0%
Month-Over-Month Trends
Compared to April, the median sale price in Plumas Lake moved 2.9% up (from $496,771 to $511,000). The number of homes sold was 20.0% up compared to the prior month (20 vs. 24). Average days on market shifted 49.6% down (129 days to 65 days).
Year-Over-Year Comparison
Compared to May 2025, the median sale price is 4.4% down (from $534,490 to $511,000). Sales volume is 35.1% down year-over-year.
What This Means
Plumas Lake's May numbers reveal a market finding its footing after a sluggish spring. The jump in sales volume from April is likely reflecting improved data collection rather than a genuine surge in buyer activity, so the real story lies elsewhere. What's genuinely encouraging is the dramatic improvement in days on market—dropping from 129 to 65 days—suggesting homes are moving considerably faster. This acceleration indicates stronger buyer interest, particularly as we head into peak summer buying season.
Pricing tells a more complicated tale. While the median price climbed nearly 3 percent month-over-month, the year-over-year decline of 4.4 percent shows the market is still softer than this time last year. That said, homes are now selling at exactly list price, which is healthier than the discounting we've seen in tougher conditions. The current inventory of 194 listings is substantial but manageable, with sellers asking around $539K—notably higher than what's actually selling at $511K. This gap suggests some price adjustment is still needed.
Overall, Plumas Lake appears to be stabilizing. Faster selling times combined with price equilibrium suggest we're transitioning out of a buyer's market, though competition hasn't heated up enough to push prices significantly higher yet.
Plumas Lake Sales by Zip Code
| Zip Code | Homes Sold | Median Price | Avg $/SqFt | Avg DOM |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 95961 | 24 | $511,000 | $249 | 65 |
Sales by Property Type
| Property Type | Homes Sold | Median Price | Avg $/SqFt |
|---|---|---|---|
| SINGLE_FAMILY | 19 | $530,000 | $249 |
| LAND | 5 | $455,000 | N/A |
Sales by Price Range
| Price Range | Homes Sold |
|---|---|
| $300K - $399K | 1 |
| $400K - $499K | 11 |
| $500K - $749K | 12 |
Current Active Listings
As of this report, there are 194 active listings in Plumas Lake with a median asking price of $538,770 and an average of 26 days on market.
Thinking About Selling Your Plumas Lake Home?
If you're a homeowner in Plumas Lake considering selling, you have options. While the traditional market is one route, selling directly for cash can save you time, commissions, and the hassle of repairs and showings. We buy houses in Plumas Lake and throughout Yuba County — get a no-obligation cash offer today.